I am an Affilate!

I hope you enjoy any product or service that I recommend. :) Just so you understand, I may take a share of any sales or other compensation from the links on this page. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Thanks if you use my links, I really appreciate your support.

Can Cats Eat Popsicles? (Or are Catsicles better?)

If you are keen to give your cat a treat (Click here to see my best one, on Amazon) you may have considered a popsicle. But, is that any good for them?

Can cats eat popsicles?

Cats can eat popsicles but it is recommended. This is because of the sugar and artificial sweeteners it has. Also, it may taste great to us, but cats are indifferent. For dogs, it is known to cause liver damage, but for cats, this has not been proven. But, it still offers them no nutritional benefits.

My Best 3 Cat Treats

Description Image My Rating
01. Temptations Cat Treats (My Best)
Click here for the price on Amazon

5 stars
02. Crunchy Cat Treats
Click here for the price on Amazon
03. Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats
Click here for the price on Amazon
4 stars

So, now you know that cats should avoid popsicles. But, can cats even taste the sugar in popsicles? Do cats appreciate frozen treats in general? What are catsicles? Keep reading to get these answers, and more.


What is a Popsicle?

Can cats eat popsicles?

Can cats eat popsicles?

According to Wikipedia, popsicles are water or milk-based treats. Unlike ice cream, they are not whipped before freezing them, making them a truly frozen treat. They have a stick frozen into them to make them easy to handle.

You have likely heard of popsicles before, but it’s worth making sure we are on the same page. For your info, they are also referred to as ice lollies, or ice pops. So, now you know what a popsicle is.

Can cats taste the sugar in a popsicle?

Cats cannot taste the sugar in a popsicle. Unlike us humans, they do not have the same taste buds as us that can detect the flavor of the sugar. also, their bodies cannot process the sugar the same as us, due to their lack of insulin. Which, leaves them susceptible to diabetes.

Many new cat owners assume cats will love the same sugar treats as them, but the reality is, they will not. So, not only are these, so-called, treats, bad for them, they also offer no real enjoyment. So, now you know that cats can’t taste sugar and why.

Do cats like frozen treats?

Cats can still appreciate frozen treats, but not the type that you may enjoy. They will prefer catsicles or natural frozen treats that do not have any added sugar or sweeteners. This is better for them than the usual offerings.

Most cat owners enjoy treating their cats (Click here to see my best one, on Amazon), but tend to choose the wrong frozen options. So, now you know what frozen treats they will prefer, such as catsicles (more on this later).

What Are Catcicles?

Catsicles are nutritional frozen treats for cats. Unlike popsicles, they are homemade and do not have added sugars or sweeteners. They are ideal for cat lovers that want to treat their cat in the summer months.

Of course, cat lovers know that cats are food lovers. You should feed a balanced diet to keep them healthy, whether that be a protein-based food or the occasional treat (Click here to see the availability, on Amazon), so keep reading to get some ideas to feed your cats with creative foods, in particular, catsicles. Keep reading for some amazingly creative catsicle ideas.

Do you have the essential items to make a catsicle?

So, if you consider this creative food you need to have a few things prepared, but there is some flexibility, mind you. First of all, if you want to keep your cat healthy and hydrated during summer you should consider catsicles as an occasional food choice.

You should make catsicles using cat-friendly food that is freezable, and some creative molds (Click here to see why I like this one, on Amazon) to pour the mixture and freeze with.

You can select the food based on your cat’s preferences because, for example, some cats do not prefer tuna, right? So, in this case, you can treat him with another cat food instead (What about Moss? Click here). If you have the essential items you can start making some creative food for your cat.

Why make catsicles for your cats?

Frozen foods are awesome during the summer because it is pretty hot and, depending on where you live, some people cannot survive the heat. You should bear in mind if you are a cat lover, treating your cats with popsicles would not be healthy, so instead make sure to treat your cat with “catsicles”.

As your cats need to be hydrated during warm seasons why not make them a special dish by mixing their cat food or cat-friendly food?

When making the catsicle you should not cut corners with their nutrition. As you may already know, cats are picky when it comes to food so you should try to feed them with their favorites.

The Goat Milk Catsicle Recipe

If you want to make a goat milk catsicle you should have the following ingredients:

  • goat milk​
  • Dixie cup
  • Water.

As you know, goat milk is healthy. Some cats do not like goat milk so you can easily substitute with other forms of milk.

How do you make a catsicle from goat milk? You should mix the goat milk with water. You should not add too much water or too little water so it should be a reasonable amount, approx 50/50.

Once you mix the ingredients you should pour it into the Dixie cup and place it in the freezer. After the mix is solid, you should place it on the cat’s tray and watch your cat lap up the catsicle treat.

Note, rather than using an ice tray it is better to use a Dixie cup or silicon tray (Click here to see the availability, on Amazon) because they are much better than the ice tray.

What should you do before trying out another recipe?

Before you try out another recipe, you should check whether your cat likes the food.

How do you know if your cat likes the Catsicle or not?

You should let her or him lick the food at least for 10-15 minutes. You should not feed her by force because it is not recommended. After you let her or him lick you should pull the plate away and check whether it moves towards the plate.

If it comes near to the food when you pull the plate it means your cat likes the food. Sometimes your cat might not like the above recipe so let us learn some more recipes.

The Catsicle Meat recipe

If your cat doesn’t like the goat milk mixed catsicle you can simply consider the meat mixed recipe.

What do you need to make the meat mixed catsicle? The ingredients are chicken, tuna, fish, or any kind of meat protein and along with that, water, and a Dixie cup (Click here to see an example, on Amazon).

You should chop any type of meat and then mix it with water until it is fixed firmly. You should make sure to stir the meat firmly because only then it will spread to the whole mixture. Once you stir it, you should pour the mix into the Dixie cup and then place it in the freezer for about an hour.

Once it is set you should slowly cut the Dixie cup and place the catsicle on the cat tray.

What should you focus on?

If you are trying out catsicle recipes you should try any recipes actually, you do not have to limit the recipes to the above ones because you can mix the ingredients based on your cat’s preference.

If you are letting the cat try out the catsicle you should make sure to let her taste it slowly. You should also make sure to check whether it suits your cat’s stomach and if it doesn’t suit, you should try out something which suits her or his stomach. During the summer, this catsicle might be the greatest gift you for your cat.

Would it be great for your cats?

Well, if you try out the above-mentioned recipes you can be assured that the cats would love these recipes but at times, it may not work out.

You can even come up with your own recipes as well because only you know about your cat’s likes and dislikes. However, keep trying new recipes because the chances are your cat will like it.

Do you have any great recipes? What is your cat’s favorite food? You should bear in mind to consider your cat’s favorite food so you can come up with your cat’s favorite Popsicle.

Why don’t you enjoy the summer by creating a delicious Catsicle?

You can enjoy the summer by making it enjoyable even for your cats. So you can spend the time in making the delicious catsicles. You do not have to run to the store instead you can make catsicles using the items at home. The bottom line is finding the ingredient, prepare the mix, freeze it, and then serve it to your cat. So, it is that simple.

Lindsey Browlingdon